Enormous energy savings thanks to the right choice of vacuum generation

Faarvang, Denmark The Danish company Tvilum is one of the largest manufacturers of flat pack furniture for self-assembly and sells eight million pieces of furniture a year all over the world through various furniture retail chains. In its highly automated production plants, Tvilum places great importance on process safety and economic efficiency. This is one reason why Tvilum has converted the vacuum supply for two of its palletizing robots at its main plant to Busch's MINK claw vacuum technology. Palletizing flat packages has thus become trouble-free and operating costs have been drastically reduced.
Fig. 1: One of the two robots palletizing flat packages. Source: Busch Vacuum Solutions
Fig. 1: One of the two robots palletizing flat packages. Source: Busch Vacuum Solutions

Tvilum was founded in 1965 as a family business. After various mergers, it now belongs to the Danish investor group with Viking Trading ApS, Kristiansen Properties and CEO Torben Porsholdt. Today, Tvilum manufactures flat pack furniture in various styles and designs and sells them worldwide through various furniture retail chains. Tvilum's headquarters and main plant are in Faarvang, Denmark, with 450 employees. The remaining 700 employees work in two further production plants in Denmark and Poland.

At the main plant in Faarvang, the furniture parts packed in flat packages are palletized by two robots and prepared for shipping in a fully automatic process. Using both robots (Fig. 1), the flat packages are held by vacuum via suction cups and stacked on pallets. In order to generate the necessary holding force, a dry-running rotary vane vacuum pump with a pumping speed of 140 cubic meters per hour was mounted on each of the two identical robots. However, they did not provide the required holding force, with the result that packages fell off several times a day, causing the system to come to a standstill and requiring manual intervention by the staff. This also often resulted in material damage.

Peter Larsen, a maintenance technician, tried to make the automated handling process safer and added an additional rotary vane vacuum pump to each robot. These each had a pumping speed of 70 cubic meters per hour. As a result, the system became more reliable and the number of furniture packages that fell was reduced.

Another problem, however, was the noise of the rotary vane vacuum pumps. The vacuum pumps were positioned directly next to the robots and their noise level also affected nearby workstations. Peter Larsen tried to enclose the vacuum pumps, but this did not prove successful because the heat radiation from the vacuum pumps caused heat to build up inside the enclosure. 

Peter Larsen then placed the vacuum pumps in a separate room and connected them to the robots via a pipeline. This solved the problem with noise and heat radiation in the packaging room, or at least moved it elsewhere. What remained was the elaborate and costly service work. Twice a year, the vacuum pumps were serviced, and the vanes had to be replaced. 

The rotary vane vacuum pumps used were what are known as dry-running pumps. With this type of vacuum pump, the rotating vanes in the pump casing are subject to high levels of wear because they grind directly along the inside wall of the casing. The vanes containing graphite have a certain self-lubricating capacity, which slows down the wear somewhat, but cannot prevent it. As these vanes wear, there is also a loss of performance in terms of pumping speed and vacuum performance. 

Contact with Busch Vacuum Solutions was established at a trade show where Busch presented a MINK claw vacuum pump that was adjustable via a frequency converter. As a result, Peter Larsen took a closer look at this type of vacuum technology. He believed it had the following advantages: MINK vacuum pumps compress the air completely contact-free. This means that the moving parts inside the vacuum pump do not come in contact with each other. In turn, this means that there is no wear that can adversely affect performance. The contact-free compression principle also has the advantage that it is extremely energy-efficient and requires less power than a dry-running rotary vane vacuum pump. Peter Larsen saw an additional advantage in the fact that MINK claw vacuum pumps are infinitely variable in the range between 10 and 60 Hertz via a frequency converter. This allows a preset vacuum level to be accurately maintained, and thus ensures a consistently high holding force regardless of the size of the package or whether leaks in the suction cup suck in more or less "leak air".

Peter Larsen was convinced by MINK claw vacuum technology and was given advice by vacuum experts from Busch Vacuum Solution. They recommended a vacuum system consisting of two MINK claw vacuum pumps (Fig. 2), each with a pumping speed of 140 cubic meters per hour and connected in parallel with a demand-driven control system. They were installed in a separate room in January 2019 and connected to the two robots via a pipeline. Immediately after starting to use them, it became apparent to Peter Larsen that MINK claw vacuum pumps run much more quietly than dry-running rotary vane vacuum pumps. After one and a half years in operation, he can also state with reassurance that not a single package fell to the ground during this period due to insufficient holding force. In addition, the maintenance effort is minimal compared to the rotary vane vacuum pumps. The gear oil is only changed once a year just as a precaution. Since MINK claw vacuum pumps have no wearing parts, the costs for their replacement or purchase are completely eliminated. 


Fig. 2: Centralized vacuum supply with two MINK claw vacuum pumps. Source: Busch Vacuum Solutions

Another positive effect were the energy savings. Peter Larsen estimates them to be over 50 percent. Whereas four rotary vane vacuum pumps with two 4 kW motors and two 2.4 kW motors were previously installed, the two MINK claw vacuum pumps each require 3.5 kW for 50 Hz operation. Since they are controlled according to demand, full power is not usually required – meaning that energy consumption is even lower than in the calculation (Fig. 3).

Fig. 3: Calculation of the energy savings based on the nominal motor rating The often considerably lower rotational speed of the vacuum pumps and the resulting lower power consumption are not taken into account. The omission of compressed air generation for the ejectors that were previously in operation on the insertion devices is also not taken into account. Source: Busch Vacuum Solutions

Peter Larsen thus had another idea to save energy. He had previously used ejectors to generate vacuum on four insertion devices for package erectors. These devices insert the individual package sheets into the package erectors (Fig. 4). The compressed air required by the ejectors for vacuum generation was supplied by a compressor. The ejectors were removed and all four package erectors were also connected to the Busch vacuum system. The system has enough reserves so that it also supplies these package erectors with vacuum and the previously used compressor is no longer needed, which again has a positive effect on the energy balance. Inspired by these successes in optimizing process safety during packaging and the enormous energy savings, Peter Larsen is confident that he will be able to implement further optimization measures in his company using MINK claw vacuum technology.


Fig. 4: One of four insertion devices that are also supplied with vacuum by the two MINK claw vacuum pumps. Source: Busch Vacuum Solutions


Categories
Want to know more?
Contact us directly (Busch Morocco):
+212 523 31 62 61 Get in contact